Reviews for Duplicate Tabs Closer
Duplicate Tabs Closer by Peuj
127 reviews
- Rated 3 out of 5by Lemons22, 7 years agoIt works OK, but it is very slow. I'm a tab hoarder and the addon showed nearly 800 duplicate tabs when I first downloaded it. I thought it would be a simple matter of hitting the "Close all duplicate tabs" button to get rid of the tabs, but nope! That crashed Firefox. Not only that, but when I restarted not a single duplicate tab had been dealt with...so either the process removes them all or it just crashes and removes none of them. Great.
So then I started removing the duplicates one by one, which is a time consuming process considering the addon lags for a good 2-3 seconds when closing each tab. Even attempting to quickly move through the list by simply going down and rapidly clicking the x's doesn't speed it up...it's just slow. I finally just made a mouse macro that clicked through them for me using a program called Mouse Recorder Premium...for those without such a program this part would have sucked!
So I pared the list down to 500. As an experiment I wanted to see if the addon would handle 500. Nope. Crashed again, but this time it also decided to crash Firefox every single time I tried to restart it as well...great! I disabled the addon after a few crashes and FF was able to start again. When I re-enabled the addon it was clear not a single tab had been removed and I still had 500.
Finally, I ran my macro a bit more and got it down to 150 (I actually wanted to stop at 250 and see if it would handle that but I got distract and the macro had already ran it down to 150 when I check it again...oh well). Now here's the reason why I didn't just rate this thing 1 star. It actually dealt with the 150 tabs pretty easily. Click the button and POOF they're gone. So I would say for the average user this addon will work quite the treat, but if you're someone like me that has a massive duplicate tab problem, well, expect to put in some work clicking those little x's and waiting.Developer response
posted 7 years agoThanks for the review and the tests.
I though I was mad with my 100 opened tabs but it seems to be nothing. :)
To solve this I think I'll need to store more tabs information instead of query Firefox. - Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13127223, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 12438258, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14787146, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Ramzes6, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14256680, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14660450, 7 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by AhJong, 8 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13953457, 8 years ago
- Rated 1 out of 5by Firefox user 13119159, 8 years agoAs of October 2022 No longer functions at all. Removing.
Not a bad addon but could use a lot more functionality. For starters, it needs a whitelist for sites that are okay to duplicate, which is often necessary. Also, a simple "Close tab automatically" function really isn't the best way to handle a duplicate inadvertently being opened. For example, say you forget you've already got Google open and you type a search in the address bar (which I have set to auto open in a new tab). Rather than the new tab opening with the search I just typed, it switches to the old tab, with an old search in it, which is at first pretty disconcerting. In this case it makes more sense to close the old tab, not the new one, but again, maybe I actually do want them both open. There needs to be a white list. Did I say there needs to be a white list? There needs to be a white list.
RESPONSE TO DEVELOPER'S COMMENT: If you think I gave it two stars just for missing one feature, you didn't even bother to read the whole review. Two stars stands I now I don't even want to bother seeing if it's improved. You need to learn what reviews are for.Developer response
posted 8 years agoHi,
You could have made it easier and shorter to simply request a White list. :)
It has already been requested and it's planned, I just miss time.
Note: 2 stars for a missing feature seems pretty strict (even I don't care, I just share for free an add-on I've developed for me) - Rated 5 out of 5by Rebuild Morphine Carbon, 8 years agoIt could be better if there is an option to move the old tab to where the new tab would have been. Currently if you open hundreds of tabs and the old tab is in the front of the tabs, the tab bar will move all the way there, which is not good.
Reply:
I find out that if "On remaining tab" is set to "default tab behavior", the old tab will be moved to the new place, which is what I need.
Thanks for your response!Developer response
posted 8 years agoHi,
Thanks for the review!
If you are in "Auto close" mode, the behavior depends on the option "On remaining tab".
Can you give me your settings?
Also can you give me usecase of you do and what is expected (based on your settings) to be sure I understand your problem. - Rated 5 out of 5by afeenstra1990, 8 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by LeD, 8 years ago
- Rated 4 out of 5by ggg, 8 years agoThe problem is that there are cases when all duplicate tabs are closed without keeping neither of them or both
-auto-close on
-no filters
-keep newer tab (keep tab with HTTPS, keep pinned tab)
-scope: active window
The situation occurs when both tabs were loading simultaneous!Developer response
posted 8 years agoThanks for the details.
So it happens with autoclose and newer. I'll search this way.
When you write "all duplicate tabs are closed" you means only the existing one and the new one?
Did you noticed if the older tab was completely loaded? or if both tabs were loading?
I guess you haven't be able to reproduce the problem with the same URL?
****Update ******
I've found something that can explain your problem.
I'll push a fix soon. - Rated 5 out of 5by Jernej, 8 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14178284, 8 years agoSimple yet customize-able interface does the job.
Filters provide even more advanced options. - Rated 4 out of 5by k2s, 8 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by Djshino507, 8 years ago
- Rated 5 out of 5by YL, 8 years agoFeature request:
Don't show the badge and number when there is no duplicated tab.Developer response
posted 8 years agoSorry but from what I've seen in the API I cannot unload the button.
Another option would be to use the pageAction https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/WebExtensions/API/pageAction.
But by doing this you cannot access the options unless there are duplicates tabs or if you go to the "Add-ons Manager" tab (about:addons).
It seems less convenient to use.
Thanks for the review. - Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 14112220, 8 years agoVery good but has a bug:
By applying filters for ignoring both "hash part" and "search part" it will not work for duplicate tabs that have only "hash part".
For example for the following URLs one time apply only "ignore hash part filter" and another time apply both "ignore hash part filter" and "ignore search part filter".
https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/5802-perspective-transform-a-point-not-an-image#answer_8076
https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/5802-perspective-transform-a-point-not-an-imageDeveloper response
posted 8 years agoI can reproduce the bug.
I'll push a fix soon.
Thanks for the report. - Rated 5 out of 5by digitarald, 8 years agoSooo good! Taming my 99 tabs with gdocs, things to read and random assortment!
- Rated 5 out of 5by Firefox user 13593688, 8 years agoThis is super useful extension. I use it a lot.
Some suggestions for improvements:
* Allow possibility to "ignore" some open tab so it's not taken into consideration when checking for duplicates.
I had one or two situations when it would be useful (filters we not enough).
So for example when you have "duplicate tabs" list you could right click and choose "Ignore duplicate checking for this tab" (or some other better text) and this entry on "duplicate list" would get different colour or be in italic to indicate that we ignored this page. We could then click again and uncheck this option.
When tab is ignored then we don't see number that we have duplicate for it and "Close all duplicate tabs" won't close this tab.
* I have no idea what this "pin" do on different option sections ("Priority", "Filter", etc). Maybe have some hover over text that explain what it does
* Make this extension open source - this is of course you personal choice to keep it private. I just think it would be awesome and help improving this great extension even more.Developer response
posted 8 years agoYour first request is something I know as I also need to duplicate tabs. :)
I'll work on something after the whitelist feature.
About the "Priority", "Filter", etc I've tried to explain this in the description of the add-on.
Filters allows to define how you want to compare the tabs.
Priority allows to define which tabs to not close.
I'll move the code on GitHub, just to have time.
Thanks for the review. - Rated 4 out of 5by Andrew, 8 years agoThis is really handy and has a good set of options for fitting into whatever way you like to browse. You should absolutely give this a try, and open the options panel if it doesn't suit you out-of-the-box.
The one extra thing I'd like to see is an option to have settings like "ignore path" apply to particular domains only -- I'd love to be able to open four articles from the same website but reliably collapse four instances of the same web-app.Developer response
posted 8 years agoMy next move is for the white/black list rules so it should match the one extra thing you need. :)
Thanks for the review! - Rated 5 out of 5by Claudy Dark, 8 years agoWer sehr viele Tabs offen hat, verliert schon gern mal den Überblick und es können Seiten doppelt geöffnet sein.
Mit diesem Addon ist damit Schluss. Danke ;-)